What is the Difference Between Structuralism and Formalism?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

Structuralism and Formalism are two literary theories or literary criticisms that focus on the structure of a particular text. However, they have different approaches and assumptions:

Structuralism:

  • Analyzes universal, underlying structures in a text.
  • Assumes that every text has a universal, underlying structure.
  • Connects the work of a particular author with works of similar structures.
  • Interested in the "big picture" of literature and the structure of literature.
  • Closer to semiotics, linguistics, and philosophy.

Formalism:

  • Analyzes the genre, mode, form, and discourse while rejecting bibliographical, cultural, historical, and social contexts.
  • Focuses on the form of the text and the "literariness" of the text.
  • Does not search inside texts for ideas from the outside world or about the authors themselves.
  • Origin of many other literary criticism theories such as structuralism, post-structuralism, and deconstruction.
  • Study of a text without taking into account any outside influence.

In summary, the key difference between structuralism and formalism is that structuralism focuses on the universal, underlying structures of a text and connects it with other literary works, while formalism analyzes the text's form, genre, mode, and discourse without considering external factors.

Comparative Table: Structuralism vs Formalism

Structuralism and Formalism are two literary theories that focus on the structure of a particular text. Here is a table comparing the key differences between the two:

Feature Structuralism Formalism
Focus Universal, underlying structure of texts Structure of a text without considering external factors such as social and cultural influence
Assumption All literary works have a universal structure Literary works have unique structures
Approach Relates literary texts to a larger structure (e.g., intertextual connections, genres, recurrent patterns) Analyzes literary devices within the text
Influence Influenced by Swiss linguist Ferdinand de Saussure Influenced by Russian Formalism, which was in turn influenced by linguistic theory of Ferdinand de Saussure
Connection Structuralism is considered the philosophical foundation of Formalism Formalism is a more objective and scientific approach to literary criticism

Both theories are interested in the structure of literature, but Structuralism aims to identify a universal structure underlying all texts, while Formalism focuses on the unique structure of individual texts without considering external factors such as social and cultural influence.