What is the Difference Between Lying and Deception?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

The main difference between lying and deception lies in the scope and intent of the actions.

Lying involves:

  • Making a false statement knowingly and intentionally.
  • An intention to deceive is necessary for lying.
  • Lying can be further divided into Simple Deceptionists, Complex Deceptionists, and Moral Deceptionists, each with different criteria for lying.

Deception involves:

  • Intentionally causing someone to have false beliefs.
  • Deception does not require making a false statement; true statements can be deceptive, and many forms of deception do not involve making statements of any sort.
  • Deception is broader than lying and can encompass various actions, such as withholding information, "keeping someone in the dark," spin, and half-truths.

In summary:

  • Lying always involves making a false statement with the intent to deceive.
  • Deception can involve making a false statement or other actions, such as withholding information, and the intent to deceive is not always necessary.

Comparative Table: Lying vs Deception

The main difference between lying and deception lies in the intention and the type of information being manipulated. Here is a table comparing the two:

Feature Lying Deception
Definition Making an intentionally false statement with the intent to deceive others Intentionally causing someone to have false beliefs, which can be achieved through various means, including withholding information, manipulating information, or making true statements with the intention to deceive
Truthfulness Requires making a false statement Does not necessarily involve making a false statement; true statements can be deceptive as well
Success Intentional false statements need not succeed in deceiving others to count as lies An act must actually cause someone to have false beliefs in order to count as a case of deception
Moral Right Violation May involve the violation of a moral right of another or the moral wronging of another Does not necessarily involve the violation of a moral right
Examples Stating that a pimple is covered with makeup when asked, or lying about personal opinions to avoid conflict Remaining silent about certain beliefs or opinions when asked, or using half-truths to intentionally mislead someone

In summary, lying specifically involves making a false statement with the intention to deceive, while deception encompasses a broader range of actions aimed at causing someone to have false beliefs, including withholding information, manipulating information, or making true statements with the intention to deceive.