What is the Difference Between Semaphore and Mutex?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

The main difference between a semaphore and a mutex lies in their purpose and implementation. Here are the key differences:

  1. Purpose: A mutex is used to provide mutual exclusion, ensuring that only one process or thread can access a shared resource at a time. On the other hand, a semaphore is used to control access to a shared resource with multiple instances, allowing multiple processes or threads to access the resource until a finite instance of the resource becomes available.
  2. Locking Mechanism: Mutex uses a locking mechanism, where a process locks the resource, uses it, and then releases it. Semaphores, on the other hand, use a signaling mechanism with wait() and signal() methods to indicate whether a resource is available or not.
  3. Object vs. Integer Variable: A mutex is an object, while a semaphore is an integer variable.
  4. Functionality: Mutex has no wait() and signal() functions, whereas semaphores do.
  5. Ownership: A mutex can be acquired and released by the same process at a time. However, the value of a semaphore variable can be modified by any process that needs the resource.

In summary, a mutex is better suited for situations where a single shared resource needs to be accessed by multiple processes or threads one at a time, while a semaphore is more appropriate for managing access to multiple instances of a shared resource.

Comparative Table: Semaphore vs Mutex

Here is a table comparing the differences between Semaphore and Mutex:

Feature Semaphore Mutex
Type Signaling mechanism, used for coordination between processes Locking mechanism, provides mutual exclusion
Source Semaphore is an integer Mutex is an object
Operations Wait and Signal Lock and Unlock
Subtypes Counting Semaphore and Binary Semaphore No subtypes
Access Semaphore can be accessed by any process that needs some resources, but only one process at a time can change its value A Mutex object allows multiple process threads to access a shared resource, but only one at a time

In summary, Semaphores use a signaling mechanism with two atomic operations (Wait and Signal) for process synchronization, while Mutexes use a locking mechanism to provide mutual exclusion.