What is the Difference Between Primary and Secondary Allylic Carbocations?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The primary and secondary allylic carbocations are types of allylic carbocations, which are resonance-stabilized carbon structures containing a positive charge. The key difference between primary and secondary allylic carbocations lies in the location of the positive charge and the number of alkyl groups attached to the carbocation.
- Primary Allylic Carbocation: In this type of carbocation, the positive charge is placed on a primary carbon atom. A primary carbon atom is one that is attached to two hydrogen atoms and a double bond. Due to the presence of only one alkyl group, primary allylic carbocations are less stable than secondary allylic carbocations.
- Secondary Allylic Carbocation: In this type of carbocation, the positive charge is distributed on a secondary carbon atom. A secondary carbon atom is one that is attached to two other carbon atoms and a double bond. Secondary allylic carbocations have two alkyl groups, which makes them more stable than primary allylic carbocations.
The stability of carbocations can be described by the following order: tertiary carbocation > secondary carbocation > primary carbocation. This increased stability is due to the +I effect of alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon atom of the carbocation, which reduces the positive charge on the carbocation.
Comparative Table: Primary vs Secondary Allylic Carbocations
The main difference between primary and secondary allylic carbocations lies in the stability, which is determined by the number of alkyl groups directly attached to the positively charged carbon atom. Here is a comparison of primary and secondary allylic carbocations:
| Primary Allylic Carbocation | Secondary Allylic Carbocation |
|---|---|
| Less stable than secondary allylic carbocations | More stable than primary allylic carbocations |
| Contains a positive charge on a primary carbon atom, which is attached to two hydrogen atoms and a double bond | Contains a positive charge on a secondary carbon atom, which is attached to two alkyl groups and a double bond |
| Only one adjacent carbon atom to stabilize the positive charge | Two adjacent carbon atoms to stabilize the positive charge, resulting in a more stable structure |
In summary, primary allylic carbocations are less stable than secondary allylic carbocations due to the difference in the number of alkyl groups directly attached to the positively charged carbon atom. Secondary allylic carbocations have two alkyl groups, which results in a more stable structure compared to primary allylic carbocations with only one alkyl group.
- Allylic vs Vinylic Carbons
- Primary vs Secondary Alcohol
- Primary vs Secondary Valency
- Allylic vs Benzylic Halides
- Primary Secondary vs Tertiary Halogenoalkanes
- Aliphatic vs Aromatic Carboxylic Acid
- Carbocation vs Carbanion
- Classical vs Nonclassical Carbocation
- Alkylation vs Acylation
- Primary vs Secondary Metabolites
- Aromatic vs Aliphatic Aldehydes
- Acyl vs Alkyl
- Alicyclic vs Aromatic Compounds
- Carbene vs Carbanion
- Organometallic Compounds vs Metal Carbonyls
- Friedel Crafts Acylation vs Alkylation
- Carbonyl vs Carboxyl
- Terminal vs Bridging Carbonyls
- Carboxylic Acid vs Alcohol