What is the Difference Between Paget’s Disease and Fibrous Dysplasia?

Paget's disease and fibrous dysplasia are both benign bone disorders, but they have distinct differences in their etiology and manifestations.

Paget's disease is a bone disorder that occurs when new bone tissue replaces old bone, making the bone weaker. It is characterized by a problem in bone remodeling, where the normal balance between bone formation and bone resorption is disrupted. This imbalance leads to an overproduction of new bone, which is weaker and more brittle than healthy bone.

Fibrous dysplasia, on the other hand, is a bone disorder where abnormal fibrous or scar-like tissue replaces healthy bone, making the bone weaker or fragile over time. It is a nonhereditary condition in which normal bone structure is replaced by expanding cystic and/or fibrous connective tissue.

In summary, the key difference between Paget's disease and fibrous dysplasia is the underlying cause of the bone weakening:

Paget's disease: New bone tissue replaces old bone, making it weaker.
Fibrous dysplasia: Abnormal fibrous or scar-like tissue replaces healthy bone, making it weaker or fragile.

On this page

What is the Difference Between Paget’s Disease and Fibrous Dysplasia?

Comparative Table: Paget’s Disease vs Fibrous Dysplasia

Paget's disease and fibrous dysplasia are two benign bone disorders with distinct differences:

Feature	Paget's Disease	Fibrous Dysplasia
Definition	A bone disorder characterized by excessive abnormal bone remodeling	A bone disorder where abnormal fibrous or scar-like tissue replaces healthy bone
Etiology	Cause is not well understood	Mutation of Gs α gene
Age of Onset	Usually occurs in older age groups	Can affect people of any age, but more commonly seen in younger individuals
Bone Involvement	Involves multiple bones, often the pelvis, spine, femur, tibia, and sacrum	Involves one or multiple bones, with a preference for craniofacial and gnathic bones
Radiological Findings	Expanded bone with coarsened trabeculae, thickening of the internal table of the frontal bone	Broad interconnected trabeculae, fusion of lesional bone to the host bone, and peritrabecular clefting
Histopathological Findings	Marked elevation in serum alkaline phosphatase	No evidence of osteoblastic rimming and lamellar bone
Treatment	Monitoring for functional distress, deformity, or fractures, with surgical intervention considered if the lesion is encroaching on adjacent structures	No specific treatment, but monitoring for functional distress, deformity, or fractures, with surgical intervention considered if the lesion is encroaching on adjacent structures

Guilherme Mazui

Guilherme Mazui is graduated in journalism from the Federal University of Minas Gerais (UFMG) and a master's degree in Communication from the University of São Paulo (USP). In addition, he has experience in advertising writing and has worked as a content editor in several companies.