What is the Difference Between Orthodox and Recalcitrant Seeds?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

Orthodox and recalcitrant seeds differ in their ability to withstand drying and freezing during ex-situ conservation. Here are the key differences between the two:

  • Orthodox Seeds:
  • Can survive freezing and drying during ex-situ conservation.
  • Can be dried to an internal seed moisture of less than 12% water and stored at freezing temperatures.
  • Exhibit low sensitivity to desiccation, allowing them to survive for a longer time in storage.
  • Examples include most food grains, legumes, guava, capsicum, sapota, dates, and cashews.
  • Recalcitrant Seeds:
  • Cannot survive freezing and drying during ex-situ conservation.
  • Cannot be dried below relatively high moisture levels (25 to 45%) and therefore cannot be stored at subfreezing temperatures.
  • More sensitive to desiccation, leading to oxidative damage or deterioration of cells.
  • Examples include mango, avocado, cocoa, lychee, and jackfruit.

Orthodox seeds can be stored for a longer time in conventional seed banks, while recalcitrant seeds require alternative storage methods due to their inability to withstand the drying and freezing conditions used for orthodox seeds.

Comparative Table: Orthodox vs Recalcitrant Seeds

Here is a table comparing the differences between orthodox and recalcitrant seeds:

Characteristic Orthodox Seeds Recalcitrant Seeds
Moisture Content Can be dried to moisture contents as low as 5% without injury Cannot dry to moisture contents below 20-30% without injury
Storage Conditions Can be stored in conventional freezers at subfreezing temperatures Cannot be stored in conventional freezers, require moist and cool conditions
Viability Survive during drying and freezing in ex-situ conservation Do not survive during drying and freezing in ex-situ conservation
Examples Most food grains and legumes, such as Guava, Capsicum, Sapota, Dates, Cashews, and Key lime Large seeds like Mango, Avocado, Cocoa, Lychee, and Jackfruit

Orthodox seeds can survive freezing and drying during ex-situ conservation, while recalcitrant seeds cannot. Orthodox seeds can be dried to low moisture contents and are desiccation-tolerant, making them suitable for long-term storage. In contrast, recalcitrant seeds require higher moisture levels for storage and are not desiccation-tolerant, which makes their storage more challenging.