What is the Difference Between Fluxionality and Tautomerism?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

Fluxionality and tautomerism are both phenomena that involve the interchanging of atoms between different positions within a molecule or between molecules. However, there are key differences between the two concepts:

  1. Occurrence: Fluxionality occurs within the same molecule, while tautomerism occurs between two molecules.
  2. Atoms involved: Fluxionality involves the interchanging of atoms other than hydrogen, whereas tautomerism specifically refers to the interchange of protons (hydrogen atoms).
  3. Positions: Fluxionality typically involves the exchange of atoms between different positions, such as axial and equatorial positions, within a molecule. In contrast, tautomerism usually involves the migration of a proton between different positions within a molecule or between two molecules.
  4. Reactivity: Fluxional molecules are often more reactive due to the dynamic nature of their structure, while tautomeric molecules may have different reactivities depending on the position of the proton.

In summary, fluxionality and tautomerism both involve the interchanging of atoms between different positions. However, fluxionality occurs within the same molecule and involves atoms other than hydrogen, while tautomerism occurs between two molecules and specifically refers to the interchange of protons.

Comparative Table: Fluxionality vs Tautomerism

Here is a table comparing the differences between Fluxionality and Tautomerism:

Feature Fluxionality Tautomerism
Definition Fluxionality refers to the ability of a molecule to undergo dynamics in a way that some or all of its atoms interchange between different positions. Tautomerism refers to the existence of two or more isomeric forms of a compound that rapidly interconvert, usually by the migration of a proton.
Occurrence Fluxionality occurs in the same molecule. Tautomerism occurs between two molecules.
Atom Exchange Fluxionality involves the interchange of some or all atoms in a molecule. Tautomerism specifically involves the interchange of hydrogen atoms.
Spectroscopy Fluxionality can sometimes be detected via spectroscopy due to line-broadening caused by the dynamic interchange of atoms. Tautomerism can be detected by comparing the spectroscopic signatures of different tautomeric forms.

In summary, both fluxionality and tautomerism involve the interchanging of atoms between different positions. However, fluxionality occurs within the same molecule and can involve the interchange of any atom, while tautomerism occurs between two molecules and specifically involves the interchange of hydrogen atoms.