What is the Difference Between Fixed and Variable Annuities?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

Fixed and variable annuities are two types of financial products that can help build a predictable stream of income for retirement. They have some similarities but also significant differences:

Fixed Annuities:

  • Guarantee a set interest rate over a predetermined period.
  • Pay a fixed rate of return, ensuring consistent and stable income.
  • Suitable for those with a low tolerance for risk and desire predictable income.
  • May lose purchasing power over the years due to inflation, unless the buyer pays extra for an annuity that takes inflation into account.

Variable Annuities:

  • Fluctuate with the returns on the mutual funds they are invested in, meaning the value can go up or down.
  • Allow investors to choose a portfolio of mutual funds, and the performance of those funds will determine the account's growth and payout size.
  • Suitable for those with a higher risk tolerance and want the potential for higher returns.
  • May be more complex due to fees attached that cover the management of the investments, which could cut into your returns.

Both fixed and variable annuities offer tax-deferred growth, meaning interest or other gains are sheltered from current-year taxation until withdrawals start. When choosing between a fixed and variable annuity, it's essential to consider your risk tolerance, desired returns, and the impact of inflation. If you're risk-averse and desire predictable income, a fixed annuity may be better suited for you. If you're looking for higher return potential and can tolerate market volatility, a variable annuity might be more suitable.

Comparative Table: Fixed vs Variable Annuities

The main difference between fixed and variable annuities lies in the interest rate and the potential returns. Here is a table comparing the key features of fixed and variable annuities:

Feature Fixed Annuities Variable Annuities
Interest Rate Fixed interest rate, guaranteed by the issuing insurance company Interest rate fluctuates based on the performance of underlying investment portfolios
Return on Investment Guaranteed, but often lower payout during the annuitization phase Potential for higher returns, but with market volatility and company profits affecting the interest rate
Risk Level Less risky More risky due to market volatility and investment selection
Investment Options Limited to the fixed interest rate offered by the insurance company Offers a variety of investment opportunities, allowing policyholders to choose based on their risk tolerance and time horizon
Tax-Deferred Growth Tax-deferred earnings without limits on contributions Tax-deferred earnings without limits on contributions
Payout Phase Payments are carefully calculated by the terms of the annuity contract Payments may vary based on the performance of the underlying investment portfolios
Suitability Better for investors with lower risk tolerance and shorter time horizons Better for investors with higher risk tolerance and longer time horizons

In summary, fixed annuities offer a guaranteed interest rate and more predictable returns, making them suitable for individuals with a lower risk tolerance. On the other hand, variable annuities allow for potentially higher returns but come with market volatility and investment selection risks, making them more suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance and longer time horizons.