What is the Difference Between Epidural and Subdural?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

The main difference between epidural and subdural hematomas lies in their location and the type of blood vessel involved in the bleeding. Both are types of intracranial hematomas that involve bleeding outside of the brain, but they have distinct characteristics:

  • Epidural Hematoma: This type of hematoma occurs when there is bleeding inside the skull but outside the dura membrane, which is the outermost layer of the brain. Epidural hematomas typically involve an artery, such as the middle meningeal artery, and bleeding can cause pressure to build up in the brain rapidly, often within hours of the injury. They usually result from a skull fracture that tears one of the arteries supplying blood to the brain. Epidural hematomas are more common in adolescents and young adults.
  • Subdural Hematoma: This type of hematoma occurs when the bleeding exists inside the dura but still outside the brain, in the space between the dura and the arachnoid layers of the membrane. Subdural hematomas involve veins, which tend to bleed and grow more slowly compared to arteries in epidural hematomas. They are more common in older individuals, as the brain shrinks with age and the veins connecting the brain to the dura become more fragile. The elderly and alcoholics with brain atrophy are particularly susceptible since the bridging veins are stretched out and the brain has more space for movement.

In terms of diagnosis, both epidural and subdural hematomas can be identified using CT or MRI scanning. Epidural hematomas appear convex, or lens-shaped, while subdural hematomas are concave or crescent-shaped. Prompt intervention is crucial for both types of hematomas to prevent worsening of the condition and potentially life-threatening complications.

Comparative Table: Epidural vs Subdural

Epidural and subdural hematomas are both types of intracranial hematomas, which involve bleeding outside of the brain. They differ in their locations and clinical manifestations. Here is a table summarizing the differences between epidural and subdural hematomas:

Feature Epidural Hematoma Subdural Hematoma
Location Between the dura and the skull Between the dura and the arachnoid membranes
Cause Usually caused by trauma, such as a blow to the head Often caused by brain atrophy, which can result from aging or chronic alcohol abuse
Onset Rapid, often within minutes of the injury Gradual, often over days or weeks
Symptoms Initially, patients may remain conscious with minimal symptoms, can become drowsy, or can progress to a coma immediately following their injury based on the size of the hematoma. Symptoms tend to be more gradual in onset and may include confusion, drowsiness, and mild to moderate cognitive impairment.
Treatment Surgical intervention is usually required to remove the hematoma and prevent further complications Treatment may require surgical intervention or, in some cases, conservative management with close monitoring.
Prevalence Intracranial epidural hematomas occur in around 2% of patients with severe head injuries. Acute subdural hematomas tend to occur in 5-25% of patients with severe head injuries.

It is important to seek urgent medical evaluation if a hematoma is detected, as both epidural and subdural hematomas can result in life-threatening conditions.