What is the Difference Between Determinism and Fatalism?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

Determinism and fatalism are two distinct philosophical concepts that deal with the nature of events and human control over them. Here are the main differences between the two:

  1. Origin of events: Determinism is based on the idea that present conditions determine future conditions, and that every event is the result of prior or coexisting events. Fatalism, on the other hand, is the belief that all events are predetermined by fate or inevitable necessity, and that human beings cannot change them.
  2. Control: Determinism implies that humans are part of the natural universe and that their thoughts, beliefs, and behaviors are influenced by previous conditions. Fatalism suggests that our choices are inconsequential, and that we should resign ourselves to the inevitable.
  3. Outcome: Both determinism and fatalism agree that our lives are ultimately decided by forces other than ourselves. However, determinism allows that our choices have consequences, while fatalism implies that our choices are irrelevant.
  4. Moral implications: Determinism undermines moral responsibility, as it suggests that our actions are determined by previous events. Fatalism is morally corrupting, as it preaches that we have no control and that our choices do not matter.

In summary, determinism is the belief that events are determined by previous conditions, while fatalism is the belief that events are predetermined by fate or inevitable necessity. Determinism implies that humans are part of the natural universe and that our choices have consequences, whereas fatalism suggests that our choices are inconsequential and that we should resign ourselves to the inevitable. Both concepts have moral implications, with determinism undermining moral responsibility and fatalism being morally corrupting.

Comparative Table: Determinism vs Fatalism

Here is a table comparing the differences between determinism and fatalism:

Determinism Fatalism
Every event in our life is decided by earlier events and actions. There is a predetermined fate that we cannot avoid, but we can take different paths leading to this fate.
The entire path of our life is decided by earlier events and actions. Our life may take whatever journey it wants, but we cannot escape our eventual fate.
Causality is the main factor, with causes leading to effects. Causes and effects have always been decided, and all instances of causation are fixed.
Determinism says that what happens has a cause. Fatalism says that causes and effects have to have happened.
The direction of our lives is decided by causal events. The direction of our lives is decided by our predetermined fate.

Both determinism and fatalism agree that our lives are influenced by forces other than ourselves, but they differ in how our lives are directed. Determinism states that every event in our life is decided by earlier events and actions, while fatalism believes in a predetermined fate that we cannot avoid, although we can take different paths leading to this fate.