What is the Difference Between Defined Benefit and Accumulation Fund?

The main difference between defined benefit and accumulation funds lies in how the retirement benefits are calculated and the level of control and flexibility the individual has over their investments.

Defined Benefit Funds:

The retirement benefit is determined by a formula, typically based on the employee's salary, years of service, and employer contributions.
The employer bears the investment risk, and the employee does not have control over the investment of their retirement savings.
These funds are generally more stable and reliable, providing greater protection from market downturns.
Most defined benefit funds are corporate or public sector funds, and many are now closed to new members.

Accumulation Funds:

The retirement benefit is based on the investment returns added to the account, and the individual bears the investment risk.
The individual has control over how and where to invest their savings, offering more flexibility and choice.
The value of the super depends on factors such as employer contributions, personal contributions, investment earnings, fees, and the chosen investment option.
Accumulation funds are more common for newer members and are typically managed by industry funds or public sector funds.

In summary, defined benefit funds offer more stability and protection from market fluctuations, while accumulation funds provide more flexibility and control over investments. The choice between the two depends on individual preferences and risk tolerance. It is essential to seek professional advice before deciding to change from one fund type to another.

On this page

What is the Difference Between Defined Benefit and Accumulation Fund?

Comparative Table: Defined Benefit vs Accumulation Fund

Here is a table comparing the differences between Defined Benefit and Accumulation Fund:

Feature	Defined Benefit Fund	Accumulation Fund
Nature	A pension plan in which an employer contributes a guaranteed lump-sum upon the employee's retirement, based on factors such as age, number of years of service, and pensionable earnings.	A fund used by nonprofit organizations like societies, charities, and clubs, to set aside funds for future purposes.
Funding	Funded by employers.	Funded by both employer and employee contributions.
Investment Management	Employer assumes all investment risks, and employees do not have individual accounts.	Employees are responsible for managing their own retirement investments, and they have individual accounts.
Retirement Income Delivery	Provides a fixed and stable income stream in retirement, based on the employee's tenure and salary.	The retirement income depends on the amount contributed and market fluctuations.
Administration Costs	Complex actuarial projections and insurance for guarantees result in high administration costs.	Typically lower administration costs.

In summary, a Defined Benefit Fund is a pension plan funded by the employer, which provides a guaranteed lump-sum upon the employee's retirement. In contrast, an Accumulation Fund is used by nonprofit organizations to set aside funds for future purposes, funded by both employer and employee contributions, and the retirement income depends on the amount contributed and market fluctuations.

Guilherme Mazui

Guilherme Mazui is graduated in journalism from the Federal University of Minas Gerais (UFMG) and a master's degree in Communication from the University of São Paulo (USP). In addition, he has experience in advertising writing and has worked as a content editor in several companies.