What is the Difference Between Close Market and Open Market?

🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚

The difference between a closed market and an open market lies in the level of accessibility, competition, and government regulations that affect market participants. Here are the main differences between the two:

Closed Market:

  • A closed market is characterized by the presence of barriers, such as tariffs, taxes, licensing requirements, subsidies, and other regulations, that restrict free-market activity.
  • In a closed market, there may be restrictions on who can participate, and pricing may be determined by methods other than supply and demand.
  • Closed markets often protect domestic producers from international competition, making it difficult for foreign companies to enter the market.
  • Examples of relatively closed markets include Brazil, Cuba, and North Korea.

Open Market:

  • An open market is an economic system with little to no barriers to free-market activity.
  • Open markets are characterized by the absence of tariffs, taxes, licensing requirements, subsidies, unionization, and any other regulations or practices that interfere with free-market activity.
  • In an open market, all economic actors have equal access and opportunity to participate, and prices are determined by supply and demand.
  • Open markets promote free competition and are more accessible to participants compared to closed markets.
  • Examples of relatively open markets include the United States, Canada, Western Europe, and Australia.

In reality, most markets are neither truly open nor closed but fall somewhere between the two extremes.

Comparative Table: Close Market vs Open Market

Here is a table comparing open market and closed market transactions:

Feature Open Market Transactions Closed Market Transactions
Definition Transactions that take place openly on an exchange. Private agreements to purchase or sell shares directly from a company without the use of a market exchange.
Participants Insiders, such as company officers, directors, executives, or employees, and other market participants. Insiders and the company, with no other parties involved.
Legality Legal and regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Legal but not regulated by the SEC, as they are private agreements.
Pricing No special pricing involved; insiders voluntarily buy or sell shares according to market prices. No special pricing involved; insiders and the company agree on a private transaction price.
Reporting Insiders must report open-market transactions with the SEC, providing relevant details about the transactions. Closed-market transactions do not require reporting to the SEC.
Information Availability Open-market transactions can provide insights into insiders' sentiment about the stock and can be used by other investors to gain perspective. Closed-market transactions do not provide such insights, as they are private agreements between insiders and the company.

Please note that the terms "open market" and "closed market" in the context of stock transactions are not the same as "open market operations" and "closed market operations" in the context of central banking, which refer to the purchase and sale of securities in the open market by a central bank.