What is the Difference Between Buchner and Hirsch Funnel?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚The main difference between a Buchner and a Hirsch funnel lies in their design and size. Both funnels are used for filtration purposes in laboratories, but they have distinct characteristics:
- Buchner Funnel:
- Traditionally made of porcelain, but also available in glass and plastic.
- Has a flat-bottomed, cylindrical shape with a horizontal perforated plate at the bottom.
- Vertical walls.
- Often used with a side-arm flask or vacuum adapters for vacuum filtration.
- Used to collect desired solids from liquids by vacuum filtration.
- Hirsch Funnel:
- Usually made of glass or porcelain.
- Has a conical shape with a perforated plate at the bottom.
- Walls of the funnel angle outward instead of being vertical.
- Smaller than a Buchner funnel.
- Often used for filtering smaller amounts of material or dilute suspensions.
In summary, the Buchner funnel is generally larger and has vertical walls, while the Hirsch funnel is smaller and has outwardly angled walls. Both funnels are used for filtration, but the Buchner funnel is typically used to collect desired solids, whereas the Hirsch funnel is often used to filter smaller amounts of material or dilute suspensions.
Comparative Table: Buchner vs Hirsch Funnel
The main differences between a Buchner funnel and a Hirsch funnel are their size, design, and functionality. Here is a comparison table highlighting these differences:
| Feature | Buchner Funnel | Hirsch Funnel |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Larger | Smaller |
| Design | Vertical walls | Outward-angled walls |
| Function | Used to collect desired solid from liquid by vacuum filtration method | Primarily used to separate a solid from a small volume of liquid |
Both funnels are used in laboratories for filtration purposes, but the Hirsch funnel is smaller and has a different shape than the Buchner funnel. The walls of the Buchner funnel are vertical, while the walls of the Hirsch funnel angle outward. The Buchner funnel is typically made of porcelain, glass, or plastic, and has a cylindrical shape with a horizontal perforated plate at the bottom and a side arm for connection to a vacuum source. The Hirsch funnel, on the other hand, is a conical funnel usually made of glass or porcelain, with a perforated plate at the bottom and sloped sides to facilitate the flow of liquid.
- Beaker vs Erlenmeyer Flask
- Colander vs Strainer
- Fraunhofer vs Fresnel Diffraction
- Erlenmeyer Flask vs Florence Flask
- Venturi vs Orifice
- Bong vs Bubbler
- Ostwald vs Ubbelohde Viscometers
- Burette vs Pipette
- Filtration vs Centrifugation
- Volumetric vs Serological Pipettes
- Hall Héroult Process vs Hoopes Process
- Decantation vs Filtration
- Bioreactor vs Fermentor
- Sphincter of Oddi vs Ampulla of Vater
- Gattermann vs Gattermann Koch Reaction
- Distillation vs Chromatography
- Gooch Crucible vs Sintered Glass Crucible
- Dichroism vs Birefringence
- Mohr Volhard vs Fajans Method